Design model for performance of the BONCUS

The values calculated in this model are best estimates and should be read as calculated design values.

Absorption into spray water in a counter-current packed column · removal efficiency per component, pressure drop and system curve

Printing presses: air flow over a week

Settings per press

Each press runs during production hours in cycles: on for the run time, then off for set-up and other stops, so that the on-time share equals the availability. Run and stop times vary randomly by ± the variation, and on Monday every press starts with a random delay of up to the variation × cycle time. After a few cycles the presses run independently, which gives the dynamic total. Statistics are over production time only.

Solvent mix

Inlet concentrations follow from the annual solvent load, the production hours, the air flow and the mass %. Hcp at 25 °C in mol/(m³·Pa); B = d ln Hcp/d(1/T) in K; C fraction in g/g; COD factor (ThOD) in g O₂ per g solvent. Spray water: residual after treatment = share of the absorbed solvent that remains in the spray water after water treatment and returns to the top of the column. The model uses it to calculate the concentration in the spray water (mg/l) and includes that in the calculation. Drain water = water leaving the bottom of the column.

Process

Column & packing

Packing type
Material

Choosing a type or material fills in the fields; you can then adjust them yourself. HTU and pressure drop values are indicative literature values at the reference load (see constants).

Constants

HG = HGref·(u/uref)nG·(aw,ref/aw)pG · HL = HLref·(B/Bref)nL·(aw,ref/aw)pL · aw/a according to Onda with constant cO. HTUOG = HG + HL/A. Pressure drop: Δp/H = K·F²·10β·B; flooding at Ffl = Ffl,0·10−γ·B.

Air flow range same solvent load (kg/h) at every flow

Efficiency vs spray water flow

Per component

Efficiency vs packing height

Sources and assumptions. Henry constants (Hcp at 25 °C and B) from the compilation by Sander (2023), henrys-law.org: always the top literature value (Burkholder et al. 2019, otherwise Brockbank 2013). 1-Methoxy-2-propanol: value measured at 37 °C (4.8 mol/(m³·Pa), Johanson & Dynésius) converted to 25 °C with an assumed B = 7000 K. 1-Ethoxy-2-propanol: not in the compilation; estimated (slightly less soluble than methoxypropanol), B assumed. 2-Dimethylaminoethanol: measured at high temperature and extrapolated (Nguyen 2013); as an amine it dissolves even better in acidic water. Ethyl acetate: Hcp set to 0.057 mol/(m³·Pa) (within the literature range 0.052–0.065), close to the design-program value, checked against the measured ≈ 40 % removal in the installation (literature 0.052–0.065). C fraction and COD factor (ThOD) calculated from the molecular formula (N as NH₃). Wetted area according to Onda (1968). HTU, pressure drop and flooding values per packing are indicative; ask the supplier for values at your load. Air density and gas velocity at 1 atm and column temperature; inlet concentration in mg/Nm³ (0 °C, dry). Fan efficiency is taken as constant over the frequency range; fan power and the system curve use the inlet flow in Am³/h, the basis of the measured K·Qⁿ fit. Reviewed independently for formulas, units and constants.

Check against the BAT conclusions (EU) flexography and non-publication rotogravure printing · solvent mass balance

Solvent mass balance

BAT-AELs

1.12. BAT conclusions for flexography and non-publication rotogravure printing (Decision (EU) 2020/2009)
Table 28: BAT-associated emission level (BAT-AEL) for total emissions of VOCs from flexography and non-publication rotogravure printing
Table 30: BAT-associated emission level (BAT-AEL) for VOC emissions in waste gases from flexography and non-publication rotogravure printing

Result

Basis. Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2020/2009 of 22 June 2020, BAT conclusions for surface treatment using organic solvents (STS), section 1.12 Flexography and non-publication rotogravure printing. Table 28: total VOC emissions from the solvent mass balance < 0.1–0.3 kg VOC per kg solid mass input (yearly average). As an alternative to Table 28, both Table 29 (fugitive VOC emissions < 1–12 % of the solvent input) and Table 30 (TVOC in waste gases 1–20 mg C/Nm³, daily average; upper end 50 mg C/Nm³ if the recovered solvent is reused/recycled) may be used. Total emissions = fugitive emissions + emissions in waste gases (Directive 2010/75/EU, Art. 57(4)). The permit sets the actual value within the BAT-AEL range. Links: BAT conclusions section 1.12 (Tables 28–30) · Decision (EU) 2020/2009, full text · STS BREF (JRC, 2020).

Estimate: the model's efficiency at the average air flow is applied to the whole year; solvent leaving with the waste is not an emission; solvent absorbed in the scrubber water is destroyed in the water treatment (O5) and is therefore not an emission. The solid mass input is an estimate (default 35 % of the solvent input) — replace it with the real figure from the mass balance.

Pressure drop & system

System resistance according to the measured formula Δp = K · Qn (Q in m³/h, Δp in Pa). This is the total air-side pressure drop: packing, demister, ducts and other parts together. Defaults are the values from the BONCUS analysis (K = 2.5·10⁻⁵, n = 1.74). K increases when the column fouls.

The measured K·Qⁿ applies to the packing and spray water flow at the time of measurement (reference below). With the correction on, the difference in wet packing pressure drop between the current settings and the reference is added: Δp = K·Qⁿ + Δppacking(current) − Δppacking(reference).

System curve

Fan with variable frequency drive curve at nominal frequency Δp = p₀·(1 − (Q/Qfree)²); with the drive Q ∝ f and Δp ∝ f²

Control

Fan and motor

With automatic selection, shut-off pressure and free-delivery flow are calculated from the maximum flow, the control margin and the ratio Q free / Q max; untick the box to enter them yourself.

Operating points and energy

Heat balance spray water steady state: heat to the air + wall loss = absorption heat + extra heat input

Settings

Shell and insulation

Wall type

Result

The air leaves the column saturated at water temperature (enthalpy method, Merkel). Absorption heat per component from the temperature dependence of the Henry constant: ΔH = B·R. When the equilibrium temperature is below 23 °C, the model calculates with 23 °C and shows the heating needed. Water treatment, tanks and piping outside the column can be included via the extra surface area.

Legend all inputs, constants and results with units

Symbol / fieldMeaningUnit
Printing presses (air flow simulation)
Number of pressesPresses connected to the scrubber; each press has its own settings–
Production days / hoursProduction window per week (from Monday 00:00); outside it all presses are offd, h
Base flowExtraction that is always on during the week (hall ventilation, other sources)Am³/h
Air flow when runningExtraction flow of a press while it is printingAm³/h
AvailabilityShare of production time that the press is printing; the rest is set-up and other stops%
Average run time per cycleAverage uninterrupted printing period; the stop time follows from the availability: toff = ton·(1 − availability)/availabilityh
VariationRandom spread of run and stop times (±) and the maximum start delay on Monday (as a share of the cycle time)%
P5 / P95Total air flow that is undercut / exceeded during 5 % of the production time; with the link on, P5, the average and the maximum are used as the air flow rangeAm³/h
Process
Air flow min / average / maxAir flow at operating conditions (actual m³). The model calculates with the average; minimum and maximum are calculated separately in the "Air flow range" block, with the same solvent load in kg/hAm³/h
Air temperature (dry bulb)Temperature of the inlet air; together with the humidity needed to convert Am³ to dry Nm³°C
Anaerobic reactorsCurrent design: about one anaerobic reactor per 50 m³/h spray water; number = spray water flow / 50–
COD minimum 650 mg/lBelow this COD in the drain water the concentration is too low for the anaerobic reactors; reduce the spray water flowmg O₂/l
Change of average air flowChanges the simulated average air flow by this percentage: negative = less air (higher concentration), positive = more air (lower concentration); the solvent load stays the same%
L/GLiquid-to-gas ratio (calculated): litres of spray water per Am³ of air, QL/QG. The spray water flow is the same at minimum, average and maximum air flow, so L/G changes with the air flowl/m³
Spray water flow QLWater distributed over the top of the packing (input, under the chart "Efficiency vs spray water flow"); the chart x-axis scales with itm³/h
Temperature TTemperature in the column (spray water and air after contact); determines solubility, viscosity and air density. Minimum 23 °C°C
Production hoursNumber of hours per year that the line runs and loads the scrubber: production weeks × days per week × hours per day (from the press block)h/year
Solvent input per yearTotal solvent input of the installation (I1, incl. solvent in inks). To the scrubber goes the input minus fugitive emission minus solvent in wastet/year
Fugitive emissionSolvent that escapes diffusely (not via the stack) as share of the input; Table 29 of the BAT conclusions% of input
Solvent with wasteSolvent leaving with waste (not an emission)% of input
Solid mass inputTotal solids (inks, varnishes, adhesives) used per year; reference for Table 28t/year
Table 28 limitTotal VOC emissions (stack + fugitive) per kg solid mass input; BAT-AEL < 0.1–0.3, the permit sets the valuekg/kg
Table 30 limitTVOC in the waste gas; BAT-AEL 1–20 mg C/Nm³ (50 with solvent reuse)mg C/Nm³
Required scrubber efficiency1 − (allowed total − fugitive) / solvent to the scrubber%
Wet-bulb temperatureTemperature that water approaches in contact with this air (adiabatic saturation). If the spray water is warmer, the air cools the water by evaporation°C
Max. cooling of spray waterUpper limit per pass if the air leaves the column saturated at water temperature: ṁair·(hsat(Twater) − hin) / (ṁwater·cp). Negative = the air heats the water (condensation)°C
Relative humidityHumidity of the inlet air at the dry-bulb temperature; used to calculate the dry normal flow%
Normal flow (dry)QG × 273.15/Tdb × (1 − yH₂O), with yH₂O = RH × psat(Tdb)/101,325 Pa (Magnus), Tdb = dry-bulb temperatureNm³/h
Cin (result)Total VOC concentration in the inlet air: load (t/year ÷ hours) divided by the dry normal flow (0 °C, 1 atm)mg/Nm³
Emission after scrubberOutlet concentration × normal flow × production hourst/year
Column and packing
DInternal column diameterm
H (total)Installed height of the packed bed; used for the pressure dropm
Not effective bottom / topPart of the bed that does not count for mass transfer (inlet and distribution zone); Heff = H − bottom − topm
Practical efficiency limitHighest efficiency per component achievable in practice (distribution, channelling, entrainment). If a component comes out higher in theory, an alarm is shown; with the tick box the model calculates with this limit%
BypassShare of the air that effectively passes the packing untreated (channelling, poor distribution); limits the maximum efficiency to 100 − bypass%
aSpecific geometric surface area of the packingm²/m³
HGrefHeight of a gas-side transfer unit at the reference conditions (uref, Bref, σc,ref)m
HLrefHeight of a liquid-side transfer unit at the reference conditionsm
KDry packing pressure drop constant: Δpdry/H = K·F²Pa/m per (Pa½)² = 1/m
βIncrease of pressure drop due to water: Δpwet = Δpdry·10β·Bper m³/(m²·h)
Ffl,0Gas load factor at which the column floods at (almost) zero waterPa½
σcCritical surface tension of the packing material; higher = better wetting (PP ≈ 30, PVC ≈ 40, stainless steel ≈ 75)mN/m
Solvent mix
Mass %Share of the component in the VOC mass at the inlet; normalised if the sum is not 100%
Hcp 25 °CHenry solubility constant at 25 °C (concentration in water / partial pressure); higher = more solublemol/(m³·Pa)
BTemperature dependence: Hcp(T) = Hcp,25·exp(B·(1/T − 1/298.15))K
C fractionMass fraction of carbon in the molecule, for conversion to mg C/Nm³g C/g
COD factor (ThOD)Theoretical oxygen demand for complete oxidation to CO₂ and H₂O. For these solvents the measured COD (dichromate method) is practically equal to the ThODg O₂/g
Inlet mg VOC/Nm³Inlet concentration of the component: Cin × mass % (calculated)mg/Nm³
Inlet mg C/Nm³The same inlet concentration expressed as carbon: mg VOC/Nm³ × C fraction (calculated)mg C/Nm³
Spray water: residual after treatmentShare of the solvent absorbed in the column that remains in the spray water after water treatment and returns to the top of the column (0 = completely clean spray water)%
Spray water inCalculated concentration in the spray water: xin = residual × xout, solved together with the column balance. Sets a lower limit for the outlet (Kaw·xin) and is included in the efficiencymg/l
COD spray water in / drain water outCOD of the water entering the top of the column and leaving the bottom, per component: concentration × COD factor. Total row = sum; total residual % = mass-weighted (Σ in / Σ out)mg O₂/l
Pressure drop and system (all air side)
K (system)Resistance factor in Δp = K·Qn for the whole air system (packing, demister, ducts). From the measured data of the BONCUS installation; increases with foulingPa/(m³/h)n
Packing/water correctionAdds the change in wet packing pressure drop relative to the reference conditions of the measurement (spray water flow, packing height, Kdry, β), so that a higher water flow, a taller bed or a denser packing raise the system pressure dropPa
n (system)Exponent in Δp = K·Qn; determines the shape of the system curve (2 = fully turbulent)–
ηfanOverall fan efficiency, for the shaft power P = Q·Δp/η–
Constants
cOConstant in the Onda correlation for the wetted area: aw/a = 1 − exp(−cO·(σc/σ)0.75·Re0.1·Fr−0.05·We0.2)–
nGExponent of the gas velocity in HG = HGref·(u/uref)nG·(aw,ref/aw)pG–
nLExponent of the liquid load in HL = HLref·(B/Bref)nL·(aw,ref/aw)pL–
pGExponent of the wetted area in HG (Onda: 1)–
pLExponent of the wetted area in HL (Onda: ⅓)–
urefGas velocity at which HGref appliesm/s
BrefLiquid load at which HGref and HLref applym³/(m²·h)
σc,refMaterial at which HGref and HLref apply (default PP)mN/m
γDecrease of the flooding point with liquid load: Ffl = Ffl,0·10−γ·Bper m³/(m²·h)
Results
uGas velocity over the empty column cross-sectionm/s
FGas load factor u·√ρGPa½
B (liquid load)Water flow per m² of column cross-sectionm³/(m²·h)
Wetting rate (MWR)Liquid load per m² of packing surface, B/a; guide value ≥ 0.08m³/(m·h)
Wetted area aw/aShare of the packing surface that is wet (Onda)%
Flooding loadF as a percentage of Ffl; above ≈ 70–80 % the pressure drop rises quickly%
Kaw (m)Dimensionless Henry coefficient: concentration in air / concentration in water at equilibrium–
AAbsorption factor QL/(m·QG); with A < 1 the water limits the efficiency to about A–
HTUOGHeight of a transfer unit for the component: HG + HL/Am
NTUNumber of transfer units in the bed: Heff/HTUOG–
Efficiency η1 − Cout/Cin per component and in total (including bypass)%
Outlet as CResidual emission converted to carbon, as in the solvent emission limitsmg C/Nm³
Uptake in waterDissolved solvents in the drained wash water, as concentration, load and COD loadg/l · kg/h · kg COD/h
System pressure dropTotal air-side pressure drop at the set air flow: K·QGn. This is the operating point on the system curvePa
Packing pressure drop (model estimate)Pressure drop across the wet packed bed only, according to the packing model (Kdry, β); for comparison, already included in the system totalPa
Fan powerShaft power at the operating point: Q·Δp/ηkW
Motor + VFD efficiencyCombined efficiency of electric motor and variable frequency drive; electrical power = shaft power / this efficiency–
Electricity pricePrice per kWh for calculating the annual electricity cost of the fan€/kWh
Annual energy useElectrical power at the average air flow × production hours per yearMWh/year
Heat balance on/offOn: the water temperature follows from the steady-state heat balance (min. 23 °C); off: the set water temperature is used–
Outside temperatureAmbient temperature for the wall loss°C
Extra heat inputHeat added to the spray water (heater, heat exchanger with waste heat, pump heat)kW
Shell heightHeight of the column shell that loses heat (packing, sump, distributor, demister)m
Extra surfaceAdditional heat-losing surface of tanks, piping and water treatment at the same U-valuem²
U-value wallOverall heat transfer coefficient from water/air inside to outside air, incl. wind; uninsulated PP ≈ 7, steel ≈ 12, insulated 50 mm ≈ 0.7W/(m²·K)
Heat from water to airṁair·(hsat(Twater) − hin); negative = the air heats the water (condensation)kW
Absorption heatΣ absorbed mass × ΔHabs, with ΔHabs = B·R/M per componentkW
Equilibrium water temperatureTemperature at which heat to the air + wall loss equals absorption heat + extra heat input°C
Heating neededExtra heat needed to keep the water at the temperature used (23 °C if the equilibrium is lower)kW
EvaporationWater evaporated into the air, ṁair·(Wsat(Twater) − Win); needs to be made upkg/h
Nominal frequencyMains frequency at which the fan curve applies (100 % speed)Hz
Frequency at maximum flowControl margin: with automatic selection the fan is chosen so that the maximum flow is reached at this frequencyHz
Minimum frequencyLowest frequency at which the motor may run continuously (cooling); below this the flow can only be reduced with a damperHz
Q free / Q maxWith automatic selection: free-delivery flow of the fan divided by the maximum process flow; determines the steepness of the curve–
Shut-off pressure p₀Fan pressure at zero flow (damper closed) at nominal frequencyPa
Free-delivery flowFan flow without back pressure at nominal frequencym³/h
Fan frequencyFrequency required for a flow: f = fnom·√(Δpsystem(Q)/p₀ + (Q/Qfree)²)Hz